The misunderstood legacy of Sonic ’06 and the Sonic fanbase

Video game critics at the time did not understand Princess Elise's story, or the demographic she was meant to appeal to

Princess Elise, a 17-year-old girl with dark red hair and a white knee-length dress, stands in a green grassy field with Sonic, a cartoonish blue hedgehog
Image: Sonic the Hedgehog (Sonic Team/Sega) via YouTube

“Downright creepy.” “A mess from top to bottom.”

These are a couple of the ways 2006’s Sonic The Hedgehog have been described. Countless more can be found across YouTube, Reddit, and GameFAQs threads. It’s infamous for its unfinished quality and largely poor reception, and sometimes uttered in the same breath as Superman 64 and E.T. — two other prominent gaming failures.

While the poor reception of Sonic The Hedgehog — usually nicknamed Sonic ’06 — cannot be equated to the load-bearing metaphor of E.T.’s desert burial, it is a snapshot of the series at its low point in most eyes. It was one of several games Sega delisted and pulled from circulation after 2010, after culling every single title below a certain MetaCritic threshold ahead of series refresh Sonic Colors.

"We have to do this and increase the value of the brand,” said Sega’s then-SVP Jurgen Post. “This will be very important when more big Sonic releases arrive in the future. We could make a lot of money on back-catalog Sonic titles, but let’s keep the number of Sonic games available under control. Otherwise you can have cannibalization.”

Princess Elise, a 17-year old girl with red hair, sits next to Sonic in a green grassy field. Sonic is standing to her left. They are looking at one another.
Image: Sonic the Hedgehog (Sonic Team/Sega) via YouTube

Such was the state of the Sonic IP in 2010 — and a clear line can be traced from Sonic '06 right up to this point. It’s hard to fathom now, when Sonic is a financially profitable and relevant franchise again, but this period was marked by the franchise moving way too fast and breaking far too many things. The result was a series beloved by its devoted fans, but generally shunned by the average gaming enthusiast until very recently. 

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Mothership.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.